|
According to the
Factories & Industrial Undertakings (Spraying of
flammable liquids) Regulations (s59N)
of the Labour Department of Hong Kong
a
spray room or spraying area, including any spray
booth or cabinet, where flammable liquid
spraying process is carried out must be
efficiently ventilated to open air by mechanical
means so as to remove any flammable vapour, mist
or spray arising from the spraying process.
Good
ventilation is essential to control the hazards
from spraying process which has two main
functions, namely:
(a)
to carry off and disperse the overspray
and
(b)
to reduce the concentration of flammable
vapour in air by dilution to below the explosive
level
For
1994 version of s59N, regulation 5.6-5.8 further
stipulates that:
In a
conventional cabinet-type spray booth, an air
velocity of not less than 30 metres per minute
(i.e. 0.5 metre/second) into the open frontal
area of the booth is sufficient for vapour
removal
The
shallower the booth, the higher must be the face
velocity because of rebound of the sprayed
material from the work and from the back and
sides of the booth. The duct opening of shallow
booths should be at the rear and dully baffled
to prevent direct spray from entering the pipe
For
1997 version of s59N, regulation 5 does not
specify the air velocity for vapour removal,
regulation 5 stipulates:
Where a
flammable liquid spraying process is carried
out, either in a spraying room or a spraying
area, including in the case of a spraying area
any booth or cabinet within such area, shall be
efficiently ventilated to open air by mechanical
means adequate to remove from any such room,
area, booth or cabinet any flammable vapour,
mist or spray arising from the spraying process.
Requirement of the Law for the paint mist
concentration
According to the Code
of Practice on control of Air Impurities
(Chemical Substances) in the Workplace (version
2002) of the Labour Department of
Hong Kong, proprietors are required to assess
the health risks due to the exposure of the
workers to the chemical substances commonly
found in the workplace and take adequate
measures to safeguard the workers against air
impurities. Air impurities in the workplace
should be within the Occupational Exposure
Limits for Chemical Substances in the Work
Environment.
|
DRY FILTER
SPRAY BOOTH
-------------------------------------------------------------------------
Filtering principle
|
|
There is a fan drawing overspray into a paper
filter pleated with many “V” pleats at the back
of the booth, thus, overspray resins will be
collected and clean air is allowed to be
exhausted without dropping vital air flow below
the prescribed limits.
The retention capacity of the pleated filter is
up to 25 kg/m2 , filtering efficiency
is up to 98.5%.
A fibreglass filter is added at back of the
pleated filter to increase the paint retention
capacity.
|
|
|
|
Advantages |
|
lower power consumption than Water-wash
or Water-curtain
spray booth (as no water pump is
required
and only a smaller KW motor is required)
can arrest paints from all
directions, so it is
very suitable
for spraying large or hanging objects
no water pollution and paint
sludge disposal problem
no manpower required for
spray booth cleaning
quick
to change filters
very high paint retention
(around 98%)
very low initial set up cost
|
|
"Water Curtain
Spray Booth" (with pump)
-------------------------------------------------------------------------
Filtering principle
|
|
There is a vertical water-screen to catch overspray
and carry it down into a washing tank that is located
on the bottom of the booth.
The washing tank contains
water mixture which can break down sticky overspray
resins. The broken-down resins will be collected in
this tank. However, efficiency of the screen
depends on the function of its circulating pump,
nozzles, pipework and filters which heavily depends
on the type of paints you use.
|
|
Advantages |
|
If water-based paints are used, then the booth
can work efficiently as no clogging occurs |
|
Disdvantages |
|
1. Clogging
will occur if non-water based paints are used.
Clogging in the filtering system occurs because
sticky paints will enter the pump, nozzles,
pipework and filters.
2. Shocking will result due to the rough
running of the filtering system out of clogging.
The booth’s efficiency will thus be diminished
and eventually it ceases to operate.
|
|
|
|
Applications |
|
This spray booth is only suitable for
small-batch production
|
"Water
Wash
Spray Booth" (without pump)
-------------------------------------------------------------------------
Filtering principle
|
|
This booth only requires a fan which creates a
high velocity of air flow across the surface of the
water tank. Overspray and water & oil mixture will be co-entrained into the booth
filter by the strong air which will then form an
extreme turbulence as “Tornado Effect” to scrub
the overspray in the washing tank.
Due
to the functions of water and mineral oil, each
resin particle will immediately receive an oil
coating and is distributed scatteredly. The coating
is renewed as recirculation of the particles
causes them to pass through the oil film again.
|
Advantages |
|
This booth can solve the problem of Water-Screen Spray booth
because it uses the “No-Pump Principle”- no
water screen and no pump. By filling in some
mineral oil (about 0.5” height in the water
tank) and then pour enough water (at the marked
level of the water tank) into the water tank,
the filtering system is ready to function.
The resin particles will eventually sink onto
the bottom of the washing tank as a non-sticky
silt which is relatively easy to dispose of.
Since no pump is required, no clogging in the
filtering system will occur, filtering
efficiency can be guaranteed.
|
Comparison between water-wash spray booth &
water-curtain spray booth
-------------------------------------------------------------------------
|
Water-Wash
Spray Booth (No Pump) |
Water-curtain Spray Booth (with
Pump) |
PRINCIPLE OF OPERATION
|
When the
exhausting fan of the booth is switched on, a
strong "Negative Pressure" will be created to
attract the overspray.
Overspray
and water mixture will be co-entrained into the
booth by the high velocity of air flow created by
the fan.
An extreme
turbulence as "Tornado Effect" is formed to
scrub the the overspray in the washing tank.
Only exhausted gas will flow outside - so it can
nearly 100% wash away the overspray.
Any
uncaptured overspray (VOC)
will only present in an insignificant amount and
within the OEL set by the Labour Department of
HK. |
By use of
a water circulating pump, overspray can be
washed away via water pipe, water screen plate
and water nozzle. As there are gaps between
nozzles, overspray cannot be washed away totally
(especially when the booth is equipped with
multi-layered water screen plates or with
shorter nozzle cleaning path).
Overspray
and exhausted gas will be allowed to flow
outside. |
EXHAUSTING FAN
|
Use
specially-designed exhausting fan (for spray use
only), medium pressure, large exhausting flow
rate, so no overspray will stick onto the fan,
and thus shocking will not be resulted |
Use
non-specially-designed exhausting fan, many
overspray will stick onto the fan and shocking
will be resulted |
CIRCULATING PUMP |
1. Not
required as no clogging will occur
2. No
water screen means no water rebounds (due to
small
pieces of paint sludge formed in front of the
water screen), so the object will not get water
spots on it. |
1. As water pump is
required,
sticky paint will enter into the circulating
pump, nozzles, pipework, so clogging will
occur. Shocking will be resulted due to the
rough running of the filtering system out of
clogging. As a result, the exhausting fan will
require a thorough clean-up service as shocking
occurs
2. As
overspray enters into the water pump, nozzles,
pipework, small pieces of paint sludge will from
in front of the water screen, and the object
will get water spots on it, especially during
peak spraying period. |
CLEAN UP |
By filling in adequate water and mineral oil,
paint sludge will float onto the surface of the
water tank.
Clean up once a
week or even a month is adequate.
|
Paint
sludge will deposit onto the nozzles and mesh,
so clean up process is required for several
times a day.
Even
double layers of stainless steel mesh cannot
help much in this matter. |
MAINTENANCE |
No repair is required - we have 5 years of
guarantee. |
High cost of doing a
proper clean-up
If clean-up is improper or heavy spraying duty
is required, shocking will be resulted due to
rough running of the filtering system out
of clogging. Booth efficiency will thus be
diminished and eventually it ceases to operate.
|
TARGET FOR |
Heavy spraying duty |
Sample spraying or light spraying duty |
MANUFACTURER |
Hong Kong Spraying & Machinery Industrial Co Ltd |
Non-specialized spraying equipment manufacturers
or electrical oven manufacturers |
Air sampling tests meet the requirement of UK, HK &
China
-------------------------------------------------------------------------
UK OES |
|
1.
the first sample
taken from our standard booth
2.
the second
sample taken from Chek Lap Kok
|
COMPONENT
VOC
|
OES
Limit |
Sampling
with standard Water-Wash Spray
Booth
(Shenzhen: 7/1/98) |
Sampling with Specially made Water-Wash
Spray Booth
(Chek Lap Kok:30/7/98) |
Isopropyl alcohol
|
400ppm |
<0.1ppm |
<0.1ppm |
n-butyl alcohol
|
50ppm |
<0.1ppm |
<0.1ppm |
Ethanol
|
200ppm
|
0.5ppm
|
<0.1ppm |
Methylethyl ketone |
1000ppm |
6.8ppm |
2.8ppm |
Phosphoric acid |
1mg/m3 |
0.2mg/m3 |
<0.05mg/m3 |
Conclusion
The
concentrations of five different parameters in the paint
mist were measured at Shenzhen (7-1-98) and Chek Lap Kok
(30-7-98) respectively and the results are presented. It is
concluded that the VOC (including Isopropyl alcohol, n-butyl
alcohol, Ethanol, Methylethyl ketone) and Phosphoric acid
arepresent in an insignificant amount and within the OES
limit.
A note on the quoted OES listed in the above table
The
full name of OES is Occupational Exposure Standard and it is a concentration
of an specific airborne Substance averaged over a reference
period at which there is currently no evidence that
repeated or day after day exposure by inhalation, will be
injurious to the Health of employees. The OES’s
should not be exceeded but if this does occur,
effective measure should be taken to reduce the exposure as soon
as practicable.
The OES quoted here is based on the
EH40 which is a part of The Control of Substances
Hazardous to Health (COSHH) regulations established by
the Health and Safety Executive of UK.
The objective of this regulation is
to prevent disease at workplace due to exposure of
hazardous substances.
|
Hong
Kong
OEL |
|
|
China
GB/T 16157-1996 |
|
|
|
|